Lab 10 · SG13G2Switched-capacitor ΔΣ
Goal. Build the Lab 9 loop from switched capacitors and SG13G2 switches, and find out which circuit imperfections the ideal model leaves out. Goes with Chapter 20.
Run.
python labs/spice/lab10_scds.py # three behavioural OTAs and the SG13G2 OTA, in parallel
python labs/spice/lab10_scds.py --ota sg13 # only the transistor-level OTA (labs/spice/sg13_ota.py)
python labs/spice/lab10_scds.py --n 8192
The loop is the second-order CIFB structure of Figure 20.1, run free rather than reset, so that its spectrum can be compared with the ideal model. Each integrator is the parasitic-insensitive circuit of Figure 20.2 with SG13G2 transmission-gate switches on two non-overlapping 512 kHz phases: \(C_\mathrm{s1}/C_\mathrm{i1}\) = 1.1 pF / 2.2 pF and \(C_\mathrm{s2}/C_\mathrm{i2}\) = 0.25 pF / 1 pF. The DAC connects the sampling capacitors’ input side to \(V_\mathrm{CM} \pm V_\mathrm{REF}\) in phase 2, and the 1-bit quantiser is latched at the end of phase 1. The model is single-ended with a ±0.25 V range, which stands for the chip’s fully differential ±0.5 V and keeps the integrators within a 1.2 V supply. The OTAs are behavioural (one pole, gain \(A_0\), bandwidth GBW), so that their effect can be varied. The input is a coherent tone at −6 dBFS, and the in-band SQNR at OSR 128 is compared with the ideal difference equations on the same input.
Expected results.
| Case | SQNR at OSR 128 | Integrator swing, x1 / x2 |
|---|---|---|
| Ideal difference equations | 92.4 dB | 0.31 / 0.11 V |
| SC loop, A0 = 60 dB, GBW = 5 MHz | 88.3 dB | 0.32 / 0.12 V |
| SC loop, A0 = 40 dB, GBW = 5 MHz | 83.3 dB | 0.30 / 0.10 V |
| SC loop, A0 = 60 dB, GBW = 0.5 MHz | 84.5 dB | 0.26 / 0.10 V |
| SC loop, SG13G2 folded-cascode OTAs, 2 µA each | 85.3 dB | 0.27 / 0.11 V |
With a good OTA the transistor-switch loop comes within 4 dB of the ideal model, and its integrators swing exactly as the model predicts once the loop has started. A 40 dB OTA turns each integrator into a leaky one and costs 9 dB. A 0.5 MHz OTA cannot settle in a 0.98 µs phase and costs 8 dB; it also takes 123 cycles to recover from start-up, during which its integrators sit on the rails, compared with 9 cycles for the 5 MHz OTA. The last row replaces the behavioural OTAs with the transistor-level folded cascode of labs/spice/sg13_ota.py: a PMOS input pair at a 1 µA tail, NMOS folding sinks, cascodes and a wide-swing PMOS mirror, 2 µA in all, with an ideal bias network inside the subcircuit. python labs/spice/sg13_ota.py characterises it: 57.9 dB of gain, 1.96 MHz of unity-gain frequency into 1 pF, 78° of phase margin and an output range of 0.37–0.86 V. That range is the catch: integrator 1 wants to swing ±0.31 V around 0.6 V, the OTA gives about ±0.25 V, so the peaks are squeezed (0.27 V) and the loop loses 3 dB against the behavioural OTA of the same gain. Scale \(a_1\) down, or give the first OTA a two-stage output, and it comes back. Chapter 20’s estimate of about 1 µA for a 1.2 MHz OTA sits between the two cases (the record’s window suppresses the start-up cycles, so they do not affect the SQNR). The swings are given as 99.9th percentiles after the first 200 cycles; the plot is labs/spice/out/lab10_scds.png.
Questions.
- Derive the integrator leakage that a finite OTA gain causes, \(x_1 \to (1 - \epsilon)\,x_1\) with \(\epsilon \approx (1 + C_\mathrm{s}/C_\mathrm{i})/A_0\), and the noise floor it adds at low frequencies. Does it explain your 40 dB result?
- How low can the GBW go before incomplete settling costs SQNR? Compare with the 1 % settling estimate of Worked Example 20.1.
- Add the kT/C noise of \(C_\mathrm{s1}\) in Python to the SPICE bit stream’s input-referred spectrum. Which limits the converter, quantisation or thermal noise?
- Remove the non-overlap of the clock phases. What happens, and why?
- Turn the loop into the incremental converter of Chapter 20: reset both integrators every 1024 cycles and decimate with the CoI filter of
lab9_deltasigma.py. Measure the conversion error at a few DC inputs.
Deliverable. The transistor-switch loop’s spectrum and SQNR against the ideal model, with the OTA gain and bandwidth you would specify.
All labs · Previous: Lab 9. ΔΣ by design · Next: Lab 11. ECG chain end to end